States asking for sovereignty ' Are small states key to overall stability? - Instablogs
States asking for sovereignty ' Are small states key to overall stability?
Pankaj , Shimla: Dec 17 2007
Made Popular Dec 17 2007

States asking for sovereignty ' Are small states key to overall stability?
# Support for Scottish independence has increased, with four in 10 Scots saying they would back it.
# Kosovo is gearing up for full independence, expected early in 2008.
# Independent Kashmir has also been voiced as a solution to the vulnerable part in Indian Territory.
# After a quarter of a century of Indonesian rule East Timor also got separated from the main part of the country.
# Many scholars and politicians suggest that Gaza be separated geographically from the West Bank for the better.
# Mongolia and Tibet wants greater autonomy within a Chinese state, or to get separated from China altogether.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
0 Stars
Disagree
Vinod
Shimla, India
Not really, then every sect, race, communities, ethnic tribes… will start asking for the autonomy and that will hardly solve the problem but chaos will spill over and over. As we have seen that the countries that were parted in the past were not at ease today even. There are so many example and Indo-Pak relations, Russian relations with its neighbors (e.g. poland, Check republic, Georgia ) who became independent after Russian fall in 1991, North and South Korea and the list goes on and on. Take any example and tell me that countries are at ease after segregation. And the situation is not going to change if the same happens to Kashmir, Kosovo, Indonesia or Palestine. So, autonomy is not at all a solution.
1 Stars
Agree
Rahul
ahmedabad, India
yea, if partition is the solution why not. if we talk about Kosovo, Serbs and Albanians will never settle down for sure! then it’s better to get segregated than to fight for the unification when ideologies don’t match isn’t it? or is it worth to see bloodshed for the same, well, I don’t agree! Same is the case with Kashmir, if autonomy is the solution for that violence why don’t they be freed from Indian clutches, no reason to fight or kill if autonomy can serve well to cater to the interests of the people… what say?
1 Stars
Disagree
Vinod
Chennai, India
I don’t agree with the idea of smaller states. If you tell me that smaller states help solve religious, ethnic and cultural problems, I would say,you are overlooking many other important dimensions of thought. Smaller states become financially dependent when there is a need for rapid development or even during emergencies. Smaller states suffer due to lack of human resources. Smaller states are even politically very vulnerable . Just go through the coups that have occured in the last 5 years, they are all in smaller states. There are also serious doubts over their ability to resist foreign invasion. Moreover unless smaller states occupy an economically important place in the world trade, they end up being having no voice of their own like Sri Lanka or the African nations for that matter. If it were a debate between autonomy and complete separation, autonomy is the solution. Kosovo and East Timor are results of deliberate ignorance and morally corrupt arrogance. Korea separated because US and USSR bit their pieces and raped the hermit land.
0 Stars
Agree
Several factors abound as to whether small states contribute to the overall stability.

But one thing is for sure, if independence of small states will promote peace and better communication lines among conflicting nations, then let them have it.

Bigger nations should first and foremost be at the backseat to tell objectively whether small nations can stand on their own. If they can, then they should be allowed.

Nation-building is like a child who grows as it ages. When nations are properly nurtured, then sooner or later, they can survive on their own.

Maynard Delfin
Manila, Philippines
Add your Comment