Is media escalating extremism by over sensationalising fanatics? - Instablogs
Is media escalating extremism by over sensationalising fanatics?
Pankaj , Shimla: Dec 18 2007
Made Popular Dec 18 2007

Is media escalating extremism by over sensationalising fanatics?
Yes # Sensationalising mass killers or fanatics is encouraging copy cats.
# The media practice of focusing on records, as calling one incident as ‘the worst school shooting ever’, or ‘the worst mall shooting ever’ is challenging others to become the next record-holder.
# Media should make victims the lead without glorifying the fanatic’s notorious background to remove the celebrity status from the whole episode.
No # Absolutely not, these extremists are usually more interested in the crime itself than the person who committed it.
# If the media do not sensationalise the whole episode, it’d be hard to stop the rampant speculation across the Web, speculation that could cause harm via rumor and innuendo?
# It is the act that inspires the extremists, not the celebrity status.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
2 Stars
Agree
Inspector
Lokhandwala, India
Yes media is undoubtedly escalating extremism...I’m going to have to say hype. I don’t think they have any conscience about what they lie about but addressing to the issue of over sensationalizing the extreme acts from fanatics is something they need to address, keeping aside their journalism ethics.

what am i tryin to say is that the media’s job to report on all aspects of the story is important but the more important part what i see as missing these days from the main stream media is responsibility. We have to responsibly see who he was rather than knowing that he had a profile on Orkut or Facebook for that matter. this is so irrelevant to the incident and a serious mishandling of the coverage that we unfortunately see too often these days. That’s an obligation of ours.

One can already hear the roar coming out of the mouths of many who have not been thinking of this in a critical way, particularly those well-paid mouthpieces on TV and radio masquerading themselves REPORTERS
2 Stars
Disagree
Vikas Shekhawat instablogs.com
Churu, Rajasthan, India
Media can’t make fanatics Gods, doesn’t matter how much they sensationalize the issue or use it as a propaganda machine. If bringing truth is what we call sensationalizing, there will be no truth at all. Osama is Osama not because media is leaking his tapes and holding discussions on the threats he or others like him (might) pose to society, it’s because the society, which has in fact given birth to so many Osamas, do not give a damn to many others in the making. Media has a very little role to play in escalating extremism, in fact, media is yet to learn what extremism is all about and how to represent it positively.
1 Stars
Disagree
Rahul
ahmedabad, India
i think i have some doubts regarding this notion being put on top as headline. If you say so how will you react if media hides the names of those suicide bombers who blew their bodies in middle of the busy subway killing more than 100 ppl. Won’t you feel deceived if you or your family member is a victim? Won’t you be interested in knowing the faces and what they did before getting those poor 100 ppl? I think it is very imp for the society to know the ugly faces we call extremists so that we get better equipped the next time in tackling the ppl that are just one of us and in no way a celebrity as is veiled by the ppl who believe otherwise. I think somehow ppl who believe that media is escalating extremism by over sensationalising issues want their eye lids closed…they someway don’t want to know the reality…all they want is it should not happen again but don’t want to know either if it somehow happens again. Right Inspector?
3 Stars
Disagree
Vinod
Shimla, India
You see, it’s the internal desire of some individual or you may call it the malicious satisfaction or whatever – but surely it’s something that makes them different from the others. So, to blame it on media is not worth anyway. If media brings the deeds on the limelight, it’s not media’s fault but of course faulty are those who take it other way.

It’s media’s job to report on all aspects of the news that include the background of killers without eulogizing. And if the things are brought on fore, doesn’t matter how bad they are, why to blame it on media?
0 Stars
Agree
Jacinta
queensland, Australia
Yes, media now a days is looking for the hell to come out for their channel… always exaggerating some details here and some there… and sometimes making hell out of it! it’s not merely the reporting of the incidents, they look more for the popularity of the channel. it’s noting more than a popularity stunt…and to crave for something sensational and adding fuel to it rather making public aware of the incident. Truth is altogether missing or rather partial hidden under the mind boggling facts that add to sensationalism than for interpret or meet reality…so this practice goes on…
0 Stars
Disagree
Toby
London, United Kingdom
Ha! Media is escalating extremism by over sensationalising issues? Do you think all the terror plots in all these years were due to over sensationalising issues? How abt 9/11 or 7/11? Media not only brought forth the lives that were devastated after the attacks but also made us aware of those involved. It made us know that ppl behind the ugly attacks are not always ugly but are no way the heroes and it no way forces anyone to be just like them. We can’t control the extremism with media hiding the facts and calling them names to avoid others not to follow them. I am not clear how’s that related anyway.
1 Stars
Agree
Nic
Florida, United States
whether hype or just a screw-up, i’d expect reports from the media to be accurate.
1 Stars
Disagree
Media in itself are independent bodies who have a significant role in society of reporting and investigating issues that have important impact to the general public.

Many people think media as a source of conflicts and gossips and they have a wrong impression that they only sensationalize stories. If you think media are violating any law, go to the courts and file a case so that they will be punished for what they are doing.

In cases of extremism, it is better to be more aware of the situation of possible terror attacks than to treat this as a normal thing.

Since media are able to communicate to these fanatics only tells us that authorities are lax in capturing the terrorists. In cases like this, the issue of extremism seems to be game without full force of the police to hunt terrorists.

Instead of just pointing fingers to media as ”exaggerated” storytellers, take your part in extinguishing extremism and suggest ways to the government to solve the issue of extremism.

Maynard Delfin
Manila, Philippines
2 Stars
Agree
Dinesh
Jaipur, India
Yes yes yes… media is devil’s den. They make the things pathetic. They really do not bother what will be impact of this. The hell you know e.g. if we see any news channel in India, Znews, Ajtak or any other channel, they go on repeating the news so many times irritating isn’t it? if we see the episode in UP when the police constable dragged the thief with his bike, that incident was repeated scores of time and similarly a lady constable beating a man who mistakenly taunted her on the road meted the same fate making the mockery of media that is loosing its value with that. Above all it’s a mad race going on in these channels to search for news and adding spice to it that some way is degrading the profession than telling reality.
0 Stars
Agree
Ana
Victoriaville, Quebec, Canada
You somehow expect better from the mainstream media? Media might not be escalating extremism but definitely an overstatement. I caught about the last ten minutes of some program last night but it was enough to make my blood boil. This mainstream media really sucks.
0 Stars
Disagree
Numerouno
Bilbao, Spain
Why are these folks not willing to see the facts. Well, at least I haven’t heard of anyone blaming President Bush - yet !!
0 Stars
Disagree
Tom
Helmond, Netherlands
media bridges the world, tells us about everything which perhaps in its absence we would have missed surely… you all chaps on the other side why you all fail to recon this… it has revealed he reality, making corrupt politicians answerable to people and digging it out or what not… makes us aware of all finally. Can you all on the other side know that without media, can you? I think not… while iam sitting in Netherlands how will I know what is happening in US or Russia. If media is telling what happened on 9/11 how it inspired the extremism… why not all the men start creating mess why only a few? Media is no way responsible for the bad perception of bigots… how can one put it on media? sheer blunder, misconception…
1 Stars
Agree
Nandini
New Delhi, India
The media is covertly if not overtly is providing a platform to terrorists. Of course, the role of the media is to report but in a bid to splashing a news, media often commits the cardinal error to flash a terrorist-incident related news without confirming the events and checking the credentials of the news source. Little wonder, the media loses its credibility in the long run. Therefore, the need of the hour is that media persons should indulge into retrospection and evolve a way in which the terrorists should not be portrayed as heroes. A villain remains a villain however lofty ideals one may carry.
0 Stars
Agree
Arjun
NCR, India
Yes, media to some extent is also responsible for the growing hatred in the world. The first terrorist who exploited the media for his purposes was Carlos the jackal who staged the OPEC raid. Media was used as communication means. The Osama bin Laden has done the same. Otherwise killing three thousand people should not have affected the world at all, where every year far more than that die from road accidents. But Osama with the help of media made everybody feel unsafe, leading to the Islamophobia and making the Muslim community an outsider in every developed country. This ensued that Muslims get attracted to extremism where they find self-respect and pride, which is essential for everybody. It all may seem to be the imagination of my mind but I can promise you that it is not.

The George Orwell told us in his essay how the words, especially the adjectives, are exploited for the purpose of propaganda.

Saying that media has a duty to present the facts is right, but don’t it also has responsibility to hide many facts? Many times some facts are there only to be misused. When the name of terrorists are given in media the Muslims terrorists are more spotlighted creating the wrong notion that all terrorists are Muslims, which is factually wrong, making an atmosphere where every Musilm with a beard is seen with a suspicious eye.

Media has very important function in any state that is to ask the right questions. But that is a far more difficult thing than it sounds, and erring in it without realising is very easy. So it is requested that freedom of speech which is a basic right of every human on the face of earth be exercised judiciously as its repercussions are really grave for everyone.
0 Stars
Disagree
It is too late in the day to have his debate. Yes, media did play an important role in promoting the ’causes’ of the terrorists. From the Munich Olympics massacre to the umpteen hijackings and even 911, media actually played in the hands of militants. Media always need sensational news, the terrorists provided it in abundance.

However, today it has gone beyond traditional media’s hands either to play down or over play a terror incident. The terrorists have taken matters into their own hands. They have become internet savvy. Now, every beheading is being broadcasted thru their own websites, community video sharing sites like YouTube etc. It is now not dependent upon traditional media to spread whatever they are doing.

When the Wall Street journal Daniel Pearl was murdered, not even a single TV news channel showed what it was like. But the video nonetheless, was ’leaked’ and is freely available all over the net. Same goes with many such incidences. Terrorists blowing up buses, army conveys in Iraq, suicide bombings wherever they take place, how to make bombs, hate speeches, propaganda, or whatever. Everything is available on the net.

The catch-22 situation now for the media is that they have to show (moral standings notwithstanding) because in any case they would be available to whosoever seeks the info/videos.

If an Ayman al-Zawahiri or an Osama bin-Laden or any other wants to bring out a tape, they wouldn’t depend upon the mainstream media to let their voices out. They already have the tool - Internet.

So, as I said, it’s a wee-bit late now to pin it on media (read mainstream media). The thing has gone out of every authority’s hands.
0 Stars
Disagree
Balbhadra Rana
Rajkot, India
Absolutely not. They may be mad, fanatics, destructive...... But closing our ears is not going to shoo them away.
Whatever they say should be heard by all. Firstly it will expose them to the public as to what they are. An informed citizen will be of immense help to the law enforcement agencies.
Secondly the notion of curbing the media from reporting whatever Laden or al Zawahiri says smacks of paternalism. ”The public is not clever enough and might be swayed by those madcaps.” This attitude is a sure-fire recipe to the rise of totalitarianism, which will only help the likes of the Fanatic fom Saudi Arabia.
0 Stars
Disagree
Ramya.
Chennai, India
Media is a all time and huge information kit. It’s their duty and responsibility to see that each and every happpenig news is brought to us. They take lot of risks and do all this. They deserve a pat on their back for bravely bringing all kinds of news to us. They even cover certain news events with hidden cameras and stuff which is really dangerous. Just think for whom they are doing all thus, is it not for us? From the time we wake up we watch news channels, or read news papers and listen to radio, but at the end of the day why should we blame them?
Information is wealth!

Thanks and Regards,
Ramya Tadikonda.
Add your Comment