Has Taslima become a victim to India’s vote bank politics? - Instablogs
Has Taslima become a victim to India’s vote bank politics?
Pankaj , Shimla: Mar 19 2008
Made Popular Mar 19 2008
India :

Has Taslima become a victim to India’s vote bank politics?Taslima Nasreen has finally decided to leave India. However, the decision to leave India is more political than personal, as she cited in a letter to her supporters confirming that she’s is in the worst of her health.

Ms Nasreen alleged that the Indian Foreign Minister, Pranab Mukherjee, had exerted “great mental pressure” on her to leave the country.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Agree
Yes ofcouse she has. All the Ruling Congress’ UPA wants to do is appease the minorities’ completely unreasonable demand in the process making the freedom of expression and thought completely irrelevant. First it was the artist, M.F Hussain. Now it is Taslima Nasreen, hell, rather the narrow minded Indian Government only knows who next it will target to appease the minorities with it’s divisive brand of politics.
2 Stars
Disagree
Vikas Shekhawat instablogs.com
Churu, Rajasthan, India
Certainly, the world’s largest democracy has failed the litmus test. But it would be wrong to say that the quagmire in which Taslima is trapped today is solely the making of Indian Government’s vote bank politics. As a daring writer, who believes Freedom of Speech and Expression as an Absolute and Inalienable Right, Taslima is apparently fighting a lost battle. She could have handled it more cleverly. I don’t believe that she was oblivious of the repercussions.

She don’t necessarily have to stuck up herself and defend the values she cherish. The whole world is waiting to embrace her writings and invaluable views. Why Asia? By doing this, she’s is indirectly creating a rift between people who in fact still have to come a long way to stand at par with her and comprehend the gist underneath the ink.

It’s good that she’s leaving. She need some space to pour out more masterpieces. And mind again, it’s not about vote bank politics, it’s about fear.
1 Stars
Disagree
Desh
Shimla, India
No doubt, she has become the victim of her own unruly ideology towards Islam. Yes, one may associate it with the vote bank politics, but she deserves the treatment if you keep her inane physiology as regards the Muslims in view. How can she be above the religion?
1 Stars
Agree
The Indian government has always wanted to safeguard its vote bank by pleasing the minorities, and this time its no exception! India can give shelter to the Bangladeshi Muslims and the Tibetians, but when it comes to stand with one Muslim, facing threat from her own community, our government backs out. It dreads to lose the support of its millions of fond Muslim voters, even though it means curbing the right to express in a person.
1 Stars
Disagree
Balbhadra Rana
Rajkot, India
More than Taslima feeling bad about the whole affair, I, as an Indian feels sad that my country is bowing down to radicals.
2 Stars
Agree
Yes, She has become the victim of vote bank politics. She was living in Kolkata and all of a sudden the CPM government in Bengal and the UPA government in centre realize that her stay in India is not good for country’s secular health. What kind of secularism is this?

A Muslim wearing Sherwani and a topi is secular for these leaders but sadhu wearing safron dress is communal. Talking and writing against Hindu God and Goddesses is ok but the person who tries to portray the evils of Islam is unacceptable for these leaders.

For these leaders the song ’Raghupati Raghav Raja Ram’ in Rajdhani Express is communal because it has a word ’Ram’. All, who talk about temples and ram Sethu are communal for them.

Shah Bano case has been crushed under the name of vote bank politics. In India politics decides everything and it happened in Taslima episode.

Now, I do believe all Muslim organisations would issue fatwas for Muslim voters to caste their vote in favour of Congress, other UPA allies and CPM in coming general election. This is what exactly the hidden agenda behind all the drama.
1 Stars
Disagree
Siddiqur
Dhaka, Bangladesh
In the January 2007 edition of Outlook in India, Taslima has written an article titled 'Let's Burn The Burqa. She has criticised the wearing of veils and provoked Muslim women to reject the apparel of discrimination by burning their burqas. I want to ask who has given her rights to say and write against Islamic traditions. She got what she deserved in India.
1 Stars
Agree
Sweta
Gwalior, India
Taslima has sent a letter to a news agency and revealed the trauma she was facing in Delhi. the letter is published here. This is real face of India. Indiaenews has published the text of her letter.
1 Stars
Agree
Vinit
Mangalore, India
Politicians can even sell the country to get votes to remain in power. people who run international racket of illegal kidney transplant, rapists who killed innocent kids, terrorists like Afzal Guru, artists like MF Hussien, can stay live in India but not Taslima.
1 Stars
Agree
Souransu
Calicut, India
We should invite more Taslimas, Rushdies in India to educate Indian politicians and Indian minority extremists about the teachings of Islam. Clerics cannot teach them like these intellectual Muslims can.
1 Stars
Agree
Hemant
Varanasi, India
I wonder where are Human rights activists who were jumping on the issue of death punishment to Afzal Guru and the inttelectuals who were crying on the episode of MF Hussien's property attachment for his absence in the court. I guess they don't come out for good cause. They speak only when a criminal get punishment.
1 Stars
Agree
Andy
Navi Mumbai, India
When India is a secular country what is the need of Muslim personnel law board? They always stage demonstration for palestein or Iraq or Iran but never for Indian cause. they never issue fatwas against Kashmiri terrorists killing innocent people in the valley. They never ask Pakistan to stop cross-border terrorism but issue fatwas against writers like Taslima.
1 Stars
Disagree
What happened to Taslima’s fate is an issue of ideology. Sometimes, beliefs and traditions are more than mere opinions.

Respect is a virtue and Islam is truly a powerful religion that has its own strength. Islam should be respected like any other religion.

Perhaps the Indian vote bank politics shows that Taslima is never above the law. She should abide or respect Islam even if she is against to some practices.

She should also be responsible to what she writes or suffer the consequences of her actions.
1 Stars
Agree
Chintan
Ambala, India
It's a shame that she has to leave India. Yes, definitely she is a victim of communal politics played by the Congress and the Left. Both claim to be secular while banning books by authors, bullying writers and hounding them. It is sad to see her leaving India because the 'atheist' commies in WB secretly offer namaaz and subsidize circumcision for Muslim boys during clandestine ration card distributing ceremonies to illegal Muslim infiltrators from Bangladesh.
1 Stars
Agree
Vinit
Mangalore, India
Pranab Mukherjee was once sacked from the Congress for 6 years by his current dominatrix's husband when he was the PM. It is unbelievable to see how things have changed since then. This shameless man has got no ideals. He is now ready to lick the bum of the communists who has got the Congress Party's balls to squeeze them over a myriad of issues like the Indo-US nuclear deal, fuel prices, or Taslima Nasreen.

Taslima Nasreen is a victim of the spineless Indian political game where morals, principles and ethics are non-existent things. This is a huge loss of face for us Indians. As BJP CM Narendra Modi welcomed Taslima to stay in his state of Gujarat, I hope to see her being welcomed back when this current government is replaced by real secularist right-wing parties.
1 Stars
Agree
Zain
Islamabad, Pakistan
India has done 2 things right in its otherwise anti-Islamic history. They were the first country to ban Rushdie's Satanic Verses and some of Nasreen's work. They have done the right thing by gagging Nasreen and eventually making her leave the country.

Now the Danes and the Germans can welcome her. Europe is a paradise for blasphemers.
1 Stars
Disagree
Prabhunarayan
Pondicherry, India
NO!!

I DONT THINK THAT SHE IS A VICTIM OF VOTE BANK POLITICS. SHE JUST MADE THE MISTAKE OF BELIEVING THAT INDIA IS A SECULAR COUNTRY WHICH IT IS NOT. IT IS RUN BY EITHER HINDU FUNDAMENTALS OR BY MUSLIM AGENTS FROM ACROSS THE BORDER. IT WAS JUST BY CHANCE THAT SHE HAPPENED TO BE IN INDIA DURING THE TIME WHEN MUSLIM AGENTS WERE RUNNING INDIA'S POLITICAL SHOW. THE COMMUNISTS ARE THE ONES WHO ARE MOSTLY INFILTRATED. THATS WHY WE SEE THEM ANTI-US AND PRO-MUSLIM.
1 Stars
Agree
Gaurav
Banglore, India
with the mumbo-jumbo loan waiver stunt, with the tasleema problem accounted for indian politicians esp the congress can now hope to get the best of both worlds - the hindu majority of poor farmers and the muslim hounds.

have you noticed something? wearing a skull cap and keeping beard has become very fashionable within the muslim youth today?
1 Stars
Agree
Chandni
Allahabad, India
the west bengal govt can accommodate millions of illegal immigrants from bangladesh and distribute them ration and voter cards making them legitimate indian citizens, but cannot accommodate a single woman persecuted from her motherland because she chose freedom of expression over her own personal safety.

whether the leftist west bengal govt remains in power in the next state elections following nandigram, singur etc remains to be seen.
1 Stars
Agree
Mayuri Majumdar
Kolkata, India
Of course yes! I am ashamed to be an Indian when incidents such as these happen.
2 Stars
Disagree
Gagandeep
Shimla, India
I don’t know too much about vote-bank coming into picture coz not too man Muslims bought that whole issue until CPM decided to politicize it. However, the act does smack of minority appeasement, or an effort for the same anyway. The fact is that India (read regime) has chosen to side with an entire community instead of say a particular individual with a claim to freedom of expression. Is that right? Not necessarily. But more importantly, is it justifiable? I would say yes. Think about it, commotion within home and poor relations with neighbors! India had more to loose than to gain from this situation. After all we never made claims to tolerance for artistic freedom. Maybe perhaps in policy statements, but everyone knows better by now.
2 Stars
Disagree
Gagandeep
Shimla, India
@Zain is very right. Europe is the place for her. Only thing he’s got wrong is that he has confused rational and objective with blasphemous, but no frets, he stands corrected.
0 Stars
Agree
Parul G
Delhi, India
I must say that Taslima is indeed a thankless person. Instead of showing her gratitude to India for granting her asylum, she is calling India fundamentalist nation. Cant she remember that India is the only country which let her in when whole Islamic world was after her life. As a matter of fact if she happens to commit any other blasphemy in future, then once again India is the only country in the world that wil grant her asylum.
1 Stars
Disagree
Desh
Shimla, India
I strongly back Parul’s stand. We should not have allowed her to stay in India. If such a response from a prolific writer like Taslima is kept in view, Indian Govt. has done nothing wrong in sending her back to...........
2 Stars
Agree
@parul
India is soon becoming a fundamentalist nation, not becuase of the tolerant Indian general public, but because of a few fundamentalist elements and the Indian government which dances to the fundamentalists’ tune to cling on to it’s vote bank. And there is nothing wrong in what Taslima has said. She has just spoken the truth. And this is not the first time the government at the centre has toed the fundamental line, M.F Hussain and to a certain extent Sania Mirza has been victim to the foolish fundamentalists’ ire and the government has not done anything to stp it from happening. By the way, Taslima was tortured when the government granted her the so called asylum status. It would do us all well if we remember the chain of events than just blame Taslima for our government’s string of mistakes which just don’t seem to end. If someone were to blame, then it is the Indian government and the Religious fundamentalists.
Add your Comment